Stripe vs. Every Alternative
True cost comparison: when Stripe is the right choice, and when switching would save you thousands per month.
Stripe
2.9% + $0.30Best developer experience and feature set. Pricing becomes expensive when you add international customers, Radar, Billing, and Connect on top of the base rate.
PayPal
2.99% + $0.49Higher per-transaction cost than Stripe. Strong consumer brand recognition boosts conversion for some audiences. Not competitive for large average ticket sizes.
Square
2.6% + $0.10Lowest flat rate for small transactions due to the $0.10 fixed fee vs Stripe's $0.30. Best for businesses averaging under $30/transaction. No international support.
Adyen
Interchange++ ~2.2%Interchange++ pricing passes actual card network costs through to you plus a small processing margin. At scale ($1M+/month) this is typically 0.5–0.8% cheaper than Stripe. Requires technical integration.
Braintree
2.49% + $0.49Cheaper base rate than Stripe (2.49% vs 2.9%) but higher fixed fee ($0.49 vs $0.30). Better for high-value transactions. Volume discounts negotiable above $100K/month. Part of PayPal ecosystem.
Which Processor Wins Your Scenario?
Startup — $10K/month, 100% domestic
Early-stage SaaS, all US customers
Developer experience, ecosystem, and features outweigh the marginally higher cost vs Braintree at this volume.
E-commerce — $50K/month, 40% international
Growing DTC brand with global customers
International card fees on Stripe ($50K × 40% × 1.5% = $300/month extra). Adyen's interchange pricing saves significantly.
Retail / Restaurant — $30K/month, small tickets
Average transaction size $15–25
Square's $0.10 fixed fee vs Stripe's $0.30 saves ~$0.20 per transaction. On 2,000 monthly transactions: $400/month saved.
Enterprise — $500K/month, omnichannel
Large-scale retail, online + in-store
Interchange++ pricing at this volume saves $5K–15K/month vs Stripe flat rate. Unified online + POS reporting.
Marketplace — $100K/month with Connect
Platform connecting buyers and sellers
Stripe Connect has the best developer experience despite Connect fees. Alternatives require more custom development.
B2B SaaS — $200K/month subscriptions
Annual contracts, invoices, recurring billing
At $200K/month, Stripe Billing adds $1K/month (0.5%). Braintree offers similar features without the billing markup. Negotiate.
The Rule of Thumb
Not sure which processor is cheapest for you?
Use the calculator to see your Stripe cost, then get a free audit to identify where you can save.